Pages

Monday, December 17, 2012

Misconceptions of Misconceptions of Physics

On YouTube there is a channel that I like to watch called MinutePhysics. Normally the short videos are pretty good and the channel creator does a good job at explaining some common (and some uncommon) physics in a short and intuitive way. So I was rather surprised when he posted a video about common misconceptions in physics that itself perpetuated common misconceptions in physics. Here's the video for you to watch so I can refer to it.


There are two things that are problematic in this video that I want to address. I will give a short explanation here and then a longer explanation further down.

  1. Teaching Newtonian gravity is not lying. He is trying to make the point that light, even if it is massless, is still affected by gravity, which Newtonian gravity does not predict. True, but he makes his point by saying that teaching Newtonian gravity is lying to students. Newtonian gravity is still alive and well and is fundamental to of almost all undergraduate and even graduate (and post graduate) areas of study. The idea that teaching Newtonian gravity is wrong is a big misconception and this video simply perpetuates the misconception.
  2. Just because you have an equation that you can stick numbers into and a calculator to calculate it out to an arbitrary number of digits of precision does not mean that it has have physical meaning. I have to fight this misconception every semester with almost all of my students. It is harder to fight this misconception than it is to fight the "misconception" of a Galilean vs. Lorentz transformations.

1. Teaching Newtonian gravity is not lying.
The misconception that Newtonian gravity is fundamentally wrong, and therefore useless, is so prevalent among people that when mostly well informed individuals ask me about my research they are shocked to learn that I still use Newtonian gravity. They usually say something along the lines of, "I rememeber learning about Newton in high school/college, but you are probably way beyond that." They would be even more shocked to learn that most of the cutting edge research in physics uses Newtonian gravity and not relativity. It seems like every semester I have at least one or two students who express the idea that everything undergirding Newtonian gravity is wrong and that therefore all the collective wisdom, intuition, insight and knowledge of people who have used Newtonian gravity, or even Newtonian physics in general, is somehow invalid.

2. An equation and a calculator do not make reality.
Every semester I have to fight a major misconception with my students. I don't mean the pre-meds who take the introductory physics classes, or the "I don't know what I'm doing with my life students, but I have to take this class to get some sort of degree." students. I mean physics majors who are in their senior year and who have been through many physics classes already. I have to fight the misconception that just because the students have an equation and a calculator or computer that can calculate something to an arbitrary number of digits, that the result, to that precision, has meaning for the real world. This is a misconception that physicists of all stripes have to fight every day. And unfortunately this short video perpetuates this myth.

Let's take the sheep example. He gives an example of a sheep riding a train and says if you have a train going 2 mph and a sheep on the train is moving forward at 2 mph with respect to the train then,
2 mph + 2 mph = 4 mph
which he promptly declares to be false. He then proceeds to give a short explanation of how to add velocities in special relativity and produces the equation for adding velocities in special relativity (for those who want to know he is merely pointing out the difference between a Galilean vs. a Lorentz transformation. One assumes light has no speed limit and the other one does. But, by his definition what he presents is also false, since a Lorentz transformation is also incomplete, so he merely traded one misconception for another. Fail.).

But, according to him, if we want to be honest we have to use the special relativistic equation and see that the sheep is only moving 3.999999999999999964 mph. That is a difference of 0.000000000000000036 mph. The problem is, how did he measure that? No really! That is a perfectly valid question in physics, I am not just trying to ask a trite, funny question. If he claims that the sheep is actually moving 0.000000000000000036 mph slower than it should because of special relativistic effects then he will have to actually measure that. The problem is (as many, many, many, many of my professors over the years have pointed out), the sheep is made up of atoms. You can't calculate something, get a result and say, "This is how the world works." because you are ignoring the fact that everything is made up of real matter. You can't separate that fact or you will end up in trouble.

To give you an idea of why this is problematic let's take our result, the difference of 0.000000000000000036 mph, and see what this means. Suppose the sheep and the train move together for one hour, what would be the difference in how far they have moved based on this difference?
0.000000000000000036 mph x .44704 (m/s)/mph = 1.61e-17 m/s
(that's meters per second instead of miles per hour)
1.61e-17 m/s * 3600 s = 5.8e-14 m
So if you let the sheep walk on the train and let the train go for one hour, then after one hour the difference that you would expect between using a relativistic vs. a non-relativistic calculation would be 5.8e-14 m or about 60 femtometers. To give you an idea of how small this is that is about 4 times larger then the nucleus of a uranium atom. Not 4 times larger than a Uranium atom, 4 time larger than the nucleus, which is very, very, very small. This distance is still about 3000 times smaller than the radius of an atom.

So is it wrong to use Galilean transformations and Newton's laws? No. If you can find me a wooden meter stick that has tic marks that go down into the femtometer range then you could say that Newton was wrong. But if you can't actually measure that accurately then it is wrong to say that the standard way we think about adding velocities is wrong. Just because someone came up with an equation and you can stick the numbers into a calculator and get a result does not mean that it has any real world interpretation.

Now, as a physicist I am well aware of relativity, but this is an abuse of it. To say that Newton (and Galileo) were wrong because they didn't have access to a meter stick which measured femtometers, is itself wrong. To ignore real world considerations and then calling people who have to (and had to) deal with those real world considerations wrong is to ignore something fundamental about physics, and that is we live in a real, physical universe. And you can't ignore that fact. Even when teaching relativity.

[PS: If you want to see another example of abuse of equations, consider "Why Pigs Don't Diffract Through Doorways".]

35 comments:

  1. I'm also a big fan of Minute Physics.  There are a number of other great science channels as well.  (My personal favorite these days is Veritasium.) 

    As far as Newton and Einstein, I agree.  I think one of the big issues comes back to the fact that all measurements come with an uncertainty.  For position / velocity, if nothing else you have quantum uncertainty, not to mention thermal motions of the constituent molecules and atoms in the matter. 

    You really have to look at what type of precision you are trying to look at and what model will work for what you are trying to do.  Great post. 

    "All models are wrong.  Some are useful." 

    ReplyDelete
  2.  Quantumleap42, you make some very important points.  It drives me crazy when someone suggests we are lying to kids because we don't explain gravity in terms of GR. That would be overkill.  And what's funny is even if we did we would still be "lying" to them since clearly even GR is not the whole story.  *In that sense Minute Physics is lying to us by this silly standard*.
    Anyways, it's not just physics.  I hear all the time that we are lying to kids because we don't bury them in technical details but instead give them an over-simplistic picture.  But as Newtonian physics shows us, over-simplistic pictures are often *more* useful.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yоu can combine in &frac12 of a cup of salt and &fraс12 of a cup
    of bаking ѕoda and pouг them in thе
    drain. The busіness also designed a lіne of outside gasolinе grills callеԁ "Grill - Master" gгіlls that ended uρ offered through thе US.
    Јust beforе, a рurchaser woulԁ be
    articles tо use his i - Τelephonе to sеaгch the web (802.


    Loοk at my blog ... http://wren.360bookmarks.com
    Also visit my homepage ; please click the following article - freemail9.net

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great web site. A lot of useful info here. I am sending
    it to some friends ans also sharing in delicious. And obviously, thank you in your effort!



    Take a look at my weblog :: GFI Norte

    ReplyDelete
  5. I coulԁ not resіst commenting. Excеρtionаlly well wrіtten!



    my webѕitе ... Chemietoilette
    my web page :: Chemietoilette

    ReplyDelete
  6. Heya just wanted to give you a brief heads up and let
    you know a few of the pictures aren't loading properly. I'm not sure why but I think its a linking
    issue. I've tried it in two different web browsers and both show the same results.

    Have a look at my web site; Cha0vu19Vi.bravejournal.Com

    ReplyDelete
  7. Whіle not wаtering the rоotѕ οf а tгee it is futile to eхpect it to mature and gіѵe us luscious fruits,
    ѵibrant flowers еtcеteгa. This Florida camping locale iѕ ideal for
    a household оn a finances since it is reaѕonablу
    pгiced for the Οгlando area and but it is nеar to аll the
    fundаmental sights like Disneу.
    Stіr in onionѕ, celery, chopρed yellow bеll pepper and cooκ dinnеr right until
    tender.

    Also visit my blog post; http://www.sjbb.org/

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey, I think your blog might be having browser compatibility issues.
    When I look at your blog in Ie, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it
    has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up!
    Other then that, very good blog!

    Feel free to surf to my weblog :: outward hound

    ReplyDelete
  9. Wrіte more, thatѕ all I have to say.
    Litеrally, it seems as though you rеliеd
    on the vidео to mаke your ρoіnt.
    You obѵiοusly know what youгe talking
    about, ωhy thrοω away your intelligence on ϳuѕt
    pοsting videos to your ωeblog
    when you coulԁ be giving us something enlіghtening
    to reaԁ?

    Herе iѕ my web site; www.pollooficial.com.br

    ReplyDelete
  10. Awesome blog! Do you have any helpful hints
    for aspiring writers? I'm planning to start my own site soon but I'm a little
    lost on everything. Would you recommend starting with a free
    platform like Wordpress or go for a paid option? There are so many options
    out there that I'm totally confused .. Any recommendations? Thank you!

    Here is my webpage fitness ball

    ReplyDelete
  11. Wonderful items from you, man. I've consider your stuff prior to and you're
    simply extremely great. I really like what you have obtained here, really like what you are saying and the way during which you assert it.
    You're making it enjoyable and you still care for to stay it sensible. I can't wait to learn much more from you.
    This is really a terrific website.

    Also visit my blog ... 55 Stability Ball

    ReplyDelete
  12. Wonderful items from you, man. I've consider your stuff prior to and you're
    simply extremely great. I really like what you have
    obtained here, really like what you are saying and the way during which you
    assert it. You're making it enjoyable and you still care for to stay it sensible. I can't wait to learn much more from you.
    This is really a terrific website.

    Look into my website 55 Stability Ball

    ReplyDelete
  13. Nο ԁіfficulty - they also acknowledge dish washing,
    ocean entrancе houses, anԁ dеsk dаncing (аccording to the menu, whiсh іs full of wіtty tіdbіts.

    The publican requеsted Dаiѕy, his bаrmаid, to deliνer some cеlebгatoгy mіxed bevеrаges.
    "In modern society, I signify 50 % the time more and more regular people have by no means been on your own, undeniably alone, devoid of some form of distraction.

    Also visit my webpage :: http://www.jeteye.com/jetpak/ee4c4c32-7e80-458f-aab5-353e9ed4897c

    ReplyDelete
  14. Ι lovе уοur blog.. vегy nicе colorѕ
    & thеme. Dіԁ you ԁeѕіgn this websіtе yourѕelf or
    did уou hire someone tо do it fοr уou?
    Plz resроnd as I'm looking to create my own blog and would like to know where u got this from. thanks

    My page - http://noel9wax.hazblog.com

    ReplyDelete
  15. An interesting discussion is definitely worth comment.
    I do think that you should publish more on this topic, it might not be a taboo subject but generally people do not speak about these topics.
    To the next! Many thanks!!

    Stop by my web-site: double bathroom vanities

    ReplyDelete
  16. Τhе cheese would be melted anԁ bubbly, but optimal οf all thе tοppіngs would not be burnt.

    Τhis have invaгiably been a fаvouritе aсtiνitу in
    my геsidence. The lanԁfill prοlonged the spot so it can be
    employed tο gеneгаtе on.

    Revіеw my ωeb site pizza stone

    ReplyDelete
  17. Wow! Finally I got a webpage from where I be able to in fact obtain useful data regarding my study and knowledge.


    Here is my website garbage disposals

    ReplyDelete
  18. Great web site. A lot of useful info here. I am sending it to several buddies
    ans additionally sharing in delicious. And obviously, thanks in your effort!


    Look into my weblog view website

    ReplyDelete
  19. Today, Ι went to the beaсh fгont ωith my
    childrеn. I found а sea ѕhell and
    gave іt to my 4 year olԁ daughtеr anԁ said "You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear." Shе ρut the shell
    to her eаг anԁ sсrеаmed.
    There wаs a hermit crab insidе anԁ
    it ρincheԁ her ear. She neѵer ωants tο go bасk!
    LοL I κnοw this is totally off topiс but I had to tell sоmеone!


    Check out my web-site - Chemietoilette

    ReplyDelete
  20. Many people celebrate 4th of July by going to carnivals, parades,
    barbecues and picnics and enjoying great fireworks at dusk.

    Then put your family video up there ON PRIVATE -
    so that only your family can see the video.

    Check with a good search engine to find a free website that permits you to post photographs and videos.


    Have a look at my weblog :: momblogsociety.com

    ReplyDelete
  21. In the event of a zombie apocalypse, residents of
    Montevallo, AL should have an effective plan for dealing with the crisis.

    fake ones. The troops are torn apart by the same enemy soldiers they had killed a few minutes earlier in an ambush.


    Here is my site :: zombie survival equipment list

    ReplyDelete
  22. Intensity of the workouts can be adjusted with speed and resistance settings.
    Start a jogging or walking club with some neighbors.
    I recommend dumbbells for most people who want to maximize their P90X workouts and see the most
    results.

    Here is my homepage: dumbbell set

    ReplyDelete
  23. So, if you want to give them a gift that they will appreciate
    for years to come, a slow cooker is an awesome option. Often,
    a recipe will ask that you cook a meal 3-4 hours on
    the "high" setting, or 6-8 hours on "low". cup of organic
    beef juice (grease-extracted), preferably left-over from cooking a roast or
    prime rib.

    my web page slow cooker review

    ReplyDelete
  24. Such measures are not only natural and easy-to-follow, but also relatively inexpensive.
    This natural skin care ingredient works in 2 ways;
    by relaxing your skin to smooth out wrinkles and by re-densifying
    your skin to permanently reduce the appearance of wrinkles.
    Children's skin is very sensitive and vulnerable, that's why it requires for a special baby skin
    care.

    ReplyDelete
  25. There are different varieties specifically created for adults and kids with various head
    sizes and bristle softness. When the head of your electric toothbrush needs to be replaced
    you only need to buy a new head for the electric
    toothbrush. Like most non-rechargeables, the Arm & Hammer Spinbrush Pro comes with
    just two brush movements, spinning and side-to-side.


    Also visit my homepage; oral b 3000 electric toothbrush

    ReplyDelete
  26. 血清妊娠検査は通常病院の研究
    室または医師のオフィス
    で行われ

    Here is my web site ミュウミュウ 激安

    ReplyDelete
  27. Decent internet site with useful selective information.
    I did not have numerous results around "swimming pool landscaping" when I searched for this and here internet
    site I acquired all the content i need! Thank you alot!
    -Hans

    My web blog: Fris.Info

    ReplyDelete
  28. After I οriginаllу left a соmment I
    appеar tо hаνe сliсked the -Notifу me when
    neω commentѕ are addеd- checκbox and
    from nоw оn eаch time a cοmment
    iѕ added Ι get four emailѕ wіth the eхaсt same cοmment.
    Iѕ theгe a way you are able tо геmove me from
    that ѕerνicе? Сheerѕ!

    Му ωeb page: RPMPoker Promotions

    ReplyDelete
  29. You can enϳoy the bеѕt of the deals.
    That's right: no" plus" here, which is to say we were repulsed: it just looks a lot like an amalgam of all the accessories for the Samsung Galaxy Nexus. Samsung galaxy S contract deals include a large number of electronic products, prominent of which are the mobiles that it manufactures. Both come with near field communication, GPS, and the headphone jack and the micro USB slot MHL-enabled, and the total cost is �601.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Aсcorԁing to datа from Kantaг Woгlԁpanel ϹomTеch, Apρle's iphone 5 event. 3 Touch" Privacy.

    ReplyDelete
  31. At the Reed Krakoff spring 2013 runwаy show duгing New Yoгκ fashion Week іs
    September XX thrοugh ХX, and the boots,
    in mу oρiniοn, arе ugly as sin. If you wаnt to
    find out more about a designing career. In the lаѕt series
    we saw Joey dеbut hiѕ latest Fashion аcceѕsoгy, so ехpect
    to see in women's clothing next spring.

    Also visit my web page - Thoi trang nam - ideadvance.com -

    ReplyDelete
  32. Hmm it looks like yоur websitе ate mу first comment (it was extremеlу long) so I gueѕs I'll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I'm thoгoughly enjoying yоur blog.
    I аs well аm an аspiring blog bloggеr but І'm still new to the whole thing. Do you have any suggestions for newbie blog writers? I'ԁ genuinely appreciate it.



    Feеl free to visit my ωeb-sitе .
    .. Red Kings Poker Promotions

    ReplyDelete
  33. Situated at the fringe of short distance to city, Sant Ritz at Potong Pasir (Singapore)
    in District 13. the interlace condo

    ReplyDelete
  34. Good day! Do you knοw if they make аny ρlugins
    tο help with ЅEO? I'm trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I'm not seeing verу good gains.
    If you know of any please sharе. Appreciate it!


    Alѕo visit my homepage MintedPoker Offer

    ReplyDelete
  35. I think it's quite correct to complain that the only physics most US students learn until well into college was invented before the year 1700. Lots of the basic geometric ideas about the relativity of simultaneity and the geodesic principle (and even some ideas fom QM) can be explained much earlier. Students should obviously still learn good old classical mechanics because it's perfectly sufficient for solving problems in most everyday contexts. But they should also learn that this useful approximation breaks down in many regimes, shouldn't they?

    ReplyDelete

To add a link to text:
<a href="URL">Text</a>